Dear John, I recently started seeing a man, and it was going really well although he did show signs of distrust if I went out with my friends. Anyway, after six weeks together, I found out I was pregnant and was unsure what to do about it. And when I told the man in question, he offered support and insisted that we keep our baby and live our lives together as a family.
However, only a few days later, he told me by text message that he no longer wanted to be a father and told me not to ruin my life. Consequently we finished our relationship, but now I'm pregnant and unsure what to do about it.
I have a child already and had to bring it up on my own. It was a struggle, and I don't want to go through that again. However, I don't know if i could go through with an abortion as I may be racked with guilt. I'm really confused. What should I do?
Dear John writes:
First and foremost, a woman has the right to decide what goes on in her own body. This means that the decision of whether or not you have the baby is yours, and yours alone – regardless of what the father (or, for that matter, some crotchety old agony uncle on the internet) thinks.
So, although I'm not going to phone up the Brook Clinic on your behalf, I'm also not going to tell you that having a clump of undifferentiated cells removed from your uterus is murder – as, in my opinion, it isn't. And nor is it in the eyes of the law.
Obviously, I'm not suggesting that abortion is a laugh riot, a suitable alternative to contraception or even an easy thing to do. If you decide to terminate your pregnancy, you may very well experience feelings of guilt or regret for some time after the procedure.
You may, however, find yourself incredibly relieved to no longer have to worry about bringing an unwanted child that you'd struggle to support into the world. And, as you've bought that t-shirt and must have it had it puked down countless times, there's little point in my telling you how difficult such a thing can be. So don't feel pressured by anybody.
Do what's right for you, and you alone. And tell anybody who demonises you for your decision to shut their cake holes. After all, there are plenty of kids out there who don't have anybody to worry about them, so perhaps they might like to direct their efforts there instead.
PS Regular readers will be relieved to note that I'll be coming down off my fence in time for tomorrow's answer.
Next question: Does he hate me?






































shopping spree





Comments:
Add your comment
Friday 21 November
Written by Tony
Dear John,
You may think that "a clump of undifferentiated cells" is not a unique human being but it is certainly a) not part of the mother or b) human in nature with a unique DNA code. From your argument tat no-one can interfere with what goes on inside a woman’s body, you could justify the killing of a baby one day before birth but not one day after birth. Does the baby only become human with rights after birth?
Also, there are not many "unwanted" babies in the Western world but just babies unwanted by a particular mother or father or both. It seems mad to me that we spend millions on aborting healthy babies while spending more millions on funding fertility treatment for couple desperate to have a baby. Many more couples would love to adopt a baby.
My reading of the letter was that this mother would want to keep the baby but is intimidated and scared at the prospect of going it alone. I do not minimise the problems she would face but the better choices in life are often the more difficult to pursue but this does not make them the wrong choices. If my own late mother had decided to abort me 50 years ago (when she was single and living far away from family and friends), I would obviously not be here to add my view on this. However, I can testify that I have the utmost love and respect for the choice she made in an era where there was far more stigma associated with single motherhood.
Also, it is important to realise that the guilt that may result from the abortion may last for the rest of the writer’s life and not just “for some time” and can give rise to periods of depression.
REPLY
Thursday 27 November
Written by JOHN
ONCE AGAIN YOU SHOW YOU DONT LIVE IN THE REAL WORLD,YOU NEVER CEASE TO AMAZE ME ON YOUR COMMENTS.ITS A SHAME YOU GET PAID FOR TELLING PEOPLE WHAT THEY ALREADY KNOW.
REPLY
Friday 28 November
Written by rachael
this is a very difficult desision as i myself know full well. let me explain: i got married very young and soon after having my first child i found out i was pregnant again. my husband was violent and i was "forced" to get an abortion or he'd kill my living child. neadless to say i obligued. i felt upset for a few days until i went through with it but i relised that it was the right thing to do and i don't regret it. I left him and my daughter and i went into a refuge.
Two years later i feel in love and unexpectantly feel pregnant.. my lover was married but promised to stand by me. He changed his mind a few days later though and said that he'd prefer me to abort but it was my choice. Once again i went through with it but this time i couldn't stop crying. I still regret that desision but its too late to do anything about it now.
He left his wife soon after, we got married and now have a little girl but i still think about the child i aborted.
My advice is "do what you feel is best for you".. if you dont want to go through with an abortion there are other options: adoption (People are desperate to adopt a baby) or keep it. Only you know how you will feel.
REPLY
Friday 28 November
Written by TallyPQ
It's really confusing isn't it? You know that you don't feel strong enough to look after a second child on your own but wonder how you would feel if you went through an abortion.
You sound like someone who has been bullied and is unconfident about making big decisions on your own. That is no starting point from which to bring up another child. Just imagine what it would be like for your authority and self esteem to be completely broken by the daily grind of solo child rearing with two chidren rather than one. Just think about this awful man drifting in and out of your life.
On tv soaps they always keep the baby don't they? And everything settles down eventually. That is because they are fantasies. And also because the soaps need the extra drama that decision creates. You don't. Many many women go through abortions and HAVE NO REGRETS! That is the most likely outcome for you - as long as you are still in the early stages of pregnancy. Concentrate on the child you have. Concentrate on making yourself the best, strongest mother you can. Forget about men for the time being. You seem to be so vulnerable that they won't help, they will only break things.
REPLY
Friday 28 November
Written by susangraley
you poor girl.a child can bring happiness,joy,pleasure,but only
you can decide what to do ,i wish you luck in what ever choice
you make.you are in a no win situation.men are silly thoughtless
creatures,but i hope you meet someone who will treasure you
and make you happy,
sue
REPLY
Friday 28 November
Written by Angela
It's not an easy thing when your faced with whether to have an abortion. Then again, it's not easy having to bring up kids on your own. Before I got married I already had one child bringing up on my own from when he was a baby because his father messed around on me and had so many baby mothers that I decided he was better out of my life. I fell for the lies that he was no longer with his baby mothers but I soon realised he was stringing me along. Before I met my husband, I was very cautious about letting anyone get too close to me and put up a barrier which he eventually with patience gave me time to open up and then we eventually had our baby and through that things weren't easy we broke up and made up and had other kids along the way until I realised in the end I couldn't stay with him for the sake of our kids knowing that things didn't feel right in the marriage. I chose in the end to bring up my 4 kids on my own rather than stay in a marriage where I felt trapped and not truely supported. But I have to say one thing, it made me a strong person in the end. Maybe because when I was down and I looked at my kids and the way they asked mummy are you ok, and mummy we love you made all the difference to me and the fact that I had a sister who never left me out and helped where she could made me realise I wasn't really on my own and when I see how my kids have grown and matured I know I did the right thing in not giving up on them or myself. The decision should be yours and yours only. Only you know whether you can be strong enough to bring a baby/child into this world or whether it's best out of your life. Don't let no one make that decision for you. My sister went through the same decision years ago and wanted to terminate her baby and I refused to let her because I don't personally believe in it. I know she's glad she never went through with it because now her daughter is an only child and has now given my sister 4 beautiful gran-children and my sister dotes on them and her daughter very much and helps as much as she can even though she lives so far away from us all. So please decide carefully what you intend to do and know that it's what you really want and that you won't regret it in the near future.
REPLY
Friday 28 November
Written by Julia
How can anyone seriously suggest that rather than have an abortion, a woman goes through the pregnancy and then GIVES the BABY AWAY???? If you think an abortion will be hard emotionally, giving away your live baby will be a killer. Surely a baby has the right to be wanted, rather than a mistake.
REPLY
Thursday 19 March
Written by annonymous 25 year old
To Abort or not to Abort?
I am 25 years old, sucsessful professional, and 5 weeks pregnant. I myself am quite torn. My boyfriend and I are long distance, but well in love. I only see him once or maybe twice a week as his job is so demanding. Although we have been seeing eachother for almost a year, seriously only for maybe 6 monthes. I have not met his family, nor he mine, and feel like there is a lot I don't know about him. Everything I do know, I love, but he is simply not around very often for babies or dates even. His family is on another continent. He is of very deep integrity, and I think he will likely want to keep the baby. He tells me how happy he is that we have met, and I have no doubt that he sees a future/ family with me. I am hesitant to tell him I am pregnant because 1. I don't know how I feel about it yet. 2.I definately don't want/ can't afford to bring up a child on my own. 3. I am afraid to lose. My growing sucessful career. My body. My freedom. My beauty. 4. I am afraid of what I may learn about him. As I said before, we don't see eachother often, due to his constant travel schedule. He has said to be very financially sucessful, but I really don't have any scope of what that realistically means. I intent to take a year off of work to labor a child. Under the support of my spouse. We have not spent more than a day an a half together.
We are both extremely sexual, and could not sexually be better partners. As much as we both would like to get out more often, we rarely do as when we finally do see one another, we can't seem to think of anything else. He has said to me before (separately) that he would take a different job that would allow him spend more time with his family when that time came.
I just don't feel like I know him well enough, and we are not married, or engaged or anything I was sure I would be before getting pregnant. I don't even refer to him as my boyfriend... (largely because I don't want a boyfriend, I want a friend, and then a husband)
I don't think abortion is right.. something I thought I would never do, but I am afraid to give up everything for a potentially very hard life alone, and similar to the depressing one I was brought up in. I don't think I could emotionally do the depressed single mom thing again.. as the mother.
My 28 year old sister has had three abortions. She has always told me of how horrible they were. After each one she has sworn she would never do it again.
now she is in a relationship which having babies seems years off in the future. I think she would have another one tomorrow if her boyfriend asked her to. Even though she would want to keep it. They live together, make a combined income of over 200,000, and have been attached at the hip since they laid eyes on eachother.
I already know my mother would insist I keep it, and would lay spiritual guilt on heavily.
My father would give me abstract advice telling me to do what my heart tells me. He would secretly hope I would not have it. (He is almost 70. He and his wife, who is 20 years his junior, had an unplanned pregnancy that landed him with a 2 year old.
These comments really haven't brought me much insight. Angela, your comments brought a tear to my eye, and prompted me to write this. Any advice would be appreciated.
P.s. I also had a major one night cocain and alcohol binger within a week of conception... Cocaine is not the norm for me.. but I don't wish to tell my partner about my random binge either....
REPLY